Utopia IV crew's 2021 collision lawsuit begins
The lawsuit is filed against the owners and management company of the 63-meter yacht that violently impacted an oil tanker during a charter cruise.
Over three years ago, on December 23, 2021, the superyacht Utopia IV—cruising approximately fifteen miles off the northern coast of New Providence, an island in the Bahamas—collided with the 49-meter oil tanker Tropic Breeze, causing it to sink. Despite the violent impact, fortunately there were no fatalities or serious injuries, but only three crew members suffered minor injuries. About a year after the incident, they filed a lawsuit against the yacht's owner and shipping company. The lawsuit, as reported recently, was initiated by the competent court on December 24; the grounds for the lawsuit are based on the physical injuries of the three plaintiffs sustained as a result of the impact, alleged negligence, unseaworthiness, and deficiencies in maintenance and pay, pursuant to the Jones Act, a federal maritime law in the United States.
At the time of the accident, which occurred during the night, the yacht Utopia IV had seven charter guests and a crew of 12 on board. collision of the yacht with the oil tanker It was so violent that it ripped open the stern of the vessel, causing it to sink at a depth of 2000 meters. The superyacht also sustained significant damage, requiring everyone on board to be evacuated. Fortunately, the incident did not cause any casualties, and the defendants admitted liability.
The accident, as clarified by the investigation that was conducted at the time by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) attributed the primary cause to the lack of constant vigilance by the crews of both vessels. The report revealed that neither the captain of the Utopia IV nor the captain of the Tropic Breeze was at the helm at the time of impact, and further details highlighted the unpreparedness of the Utopia IV's chief of deck duty, who was not qualified for independent watchkeeping, as well as his likely distraction due to multiple simultaneous tasks. Even the radar, inexplicably, despite being set to a limited range of three miles in what were considered good visibility conditions, had failed to prevent the catastrophe.
The Tropic Breeze, travelling at a modest five knots while carrying a dangerous cargo of marine diesel fuel and LPG, suddenly found itself facing the approaching Utopia IV at 20 knots. As an overtaking vessel, the Utopia IV should have obeyed the Colreg right-of-way rules; however, the Tropic Breeze had also failed to maintain the adequate vigilance required by the regulations in force.
The Utopia IV's closed-circuit television cameras captured images of the force of the impact: people and objects were thrown; even the yacht's captain, who was in the dining room, was thrown against a bulkhead. The alarm from the tanker was answered by a passing yacht (the Amara), which rescued the entire crew, whom the Utopia IV had been unable to board due to the rough seas.
The final damages from the collision were approximately $7,9 million, including the loss of the Tropic Breeze and 156.500 gallons of marine diesel fuel, in addition to the trauma and physical injuries to the crew members involved.
The legal proceedings, formally begun on March 24, 2025, will now involve a jury deciding whether the plaintiffs suffered damages as a result of the collision and, if so, quantifying the extent of their injuries to determine fair compensation.
The 63-meter Utopia IV, delivered by Rossinavi in 2018 and winner of numerous awards at international trade fairs for its design, is once again at the center of a legal battle that is reopening questions about navigation safety and the responsibility of shipowners.
SUBSCRIBE TO FREE SUPER YACHT 24 NEWSLETTER
SUPER YACHT 24 IS ALSO ON WHATSAPP: JUST CLICK HERE TO SUBSCRIBE TO THE CHANNEL AND ALWAYS BE UPDATED
